Before more state governments adopt the mantra of “adult time for adult crime” they need to take a breath and consult two documents that might help ensure their youth justice policies are based not on ideology, but on evidence and principle.
The first of those documents is the terrifying report by Coroner Philip Urquhart on the death in custody of Cleveland Dodd, a young man with mental health issues who died by his own hand after brutal treatment in a Perth prison.
He was barely sixteen. He knew he had problems. In the days before he killed himself he had asked for psychological help but none was forthcoming.
The second document is a slim but highly readable book that should help policymakers understand that equality before the law does not mean designing a youth justice system that treats children and young offenders as if they are adults.
That book is “The Rule of Law” by the late Tom Bingham, a former Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales. His ideas form a stark contrast with the most extreme proposals for dealing with youth crime.
The challenge is to avoid policy extremes which range from impunity right through to the other extreme of incarcerating children and young offenders in a manner that is entirely inappropriate if not dangerous.
Bingham was a realist. He believed children should be treated as children – not as adults – an idea that should be the new hallmark for youth justice in Western Australia.
What happened to Dodd is evidence of system failure. It failed a young man who had been in an out of prison since the age of twelve, but it has also failed the prison officers and staff at the Department of Justice who were part of a youth justice system that seems deeply dysfunctional.
Some of these people broke down in tears while giving evidence to the Coroner. Others were unable to return to work six months after Dodd’s suicide.
With luck, Urquhart’s shocking report should mark a turning point, not just for Western Australia but for other states that are grappling with how to deal with surging youth crime.
Urquhart’s report shows Dodd was incredibly vulnerable – with limited receptive and expressive language skills, a major depressive disorder, cannabis use disorder and a history of being denied psychological services in prison because of staff shortages.
The coroner found that the failure of the Department of Justice to arrange appointments for him with psychologists in the days before his death – despite his three requests – “is a sad example of the department’s inability to provide sufficient resources for the care and treatment of those detainees who were most vulnerable”.
He died after hanging himself in a cell that the coroner described as “deplorable and completely unhygenic”. He had a history of self harm and had repeatedly told those responsible for his care what he was planning to do.
At the time of his death he had spent 74 of his final 87 days in solitary confinement at the youth detention centre known as Unit 18 in the grounds of Casuarina Prison, just 35 kilometres south of Perth.
What happened to Dodd makes it clear that too many people in authority completely misunderstood what is meant by equality before the law.
The state’s Young Offenders Act is on the right track. It makes it clear that when young people are detained in custody it should be in conditions that are suitable – that is, suitable for children and young offenders.
But the law and public administration are two different things.
Thirteen days before Dodd hung himself, the Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia wrote to Christine Ginbey, deputy commissioner, women and young people at the Department of Justice.
That letter, which is reproduced in the coroner’s report, asks for Dodd to be urgently transferred from Unit 18. It said the conditions there were unsuitable for the detention of a young person – as required by section 7(i) of the Young Offenders Act.
He had generally been locked in his cell for all but one hour daily.
“In light of Cleveland’s significant and unlawful lockdown hours at Unit 18, both previously and currently, and the lack of education programs, it is our view that Unit 18 is not a facility suitable the detention of a young person,” the Legal Service wrote.
The Coroner came to a clear view about what should be done about Unit 18. His recommendation: close it immediately.
When deciding how to structure the replacement for Unit 18, the state government might care to consider the approach favoured by Bingham.
He believed children and other vulnerable people such as the mentally ill, should be treated differently to the rest of the adult population.
Bingham believed objective differences between categories of people justify “differentiation” – or legal treatment that takes account of those objective differences.
“Children are the most obvious example. Children are, by definition, less mature than a normal adult, and should not therefore be treated as a normal adult would expect to be treated,” he wrote.
“If convicted of a crime they should not be punished as a normal adult would be,” Bingham wrote.
These ideas are relevant in every state and territory. Around the nation, the average number of young offenders in custody in the June quarter was 884 and 81 per cent of them were between the ages of fourteen and seventeen, according to figures released this month by the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.


