To contemporary Australia, the law of blasphemy must seem like a relic from a bygone age, a curiosity which provides an insight into the redundant values of the past.
But if the debate about the government’s hate-speech law is any guide, we need to prepare ourselves for the possibility that it could be the first step towards what would amount to a new federal blasphemy law – with a twist.
It all depends on whether the government pushes ahead with plans to expand the scope of its hate-speech law after it comes into force.
For now, the hate-speech bill would introduce criminal penalties for just one category of speech – that which promotes hatred on the basis of race, colour or national and ethnic origin.Because this is the government’s response to the Jew hatred that culminated in the Bondi Beach terror attack, some might consider it odd that it has included the now notorious “religious text” defence.
This is a gift for hate preachers. If it becomes law it would undermine the government’s legitimate goal of suppressing the promotion of racial hatred and, hopefully, avoiding another Bondi.
Hate preachers would be able to go about their vile business with impunity – as long as statements promoting racial hatred include a quote from a religious text or even a mere reference.
So why would the government’s lawyers insert such a counter-productive mechanism is a bill aimed at suppressing hate speech?
The answer is that it could be a sign of things to come.
It is worth noting that Anne Aly, the government’s most senior Muslim, has made no secret of the government’s intention to expand the scope of the hate-speech bill once it becomes law in order to criminalise more categories of speech.
On Wednesday, Australian Human Rights Commission president Hugh de Kretser said the commission supported extending criminal provisions beyond race to other attributes, including religion “particularly when you are thinking about Islamophobia”.
So consider what that could mean.
Ordinary people would risk prison for publicly stating that their religion is superior to others – that the Baptist Church is superior to Catholicism, for example, or that Christianity is superior to Islam.
But if the religious text defence were to remain in place it would mean that hate preachers would be free to promote hatred, not just on the basis of race but on the new ground of religion.
Christians and others would find themselves in the same boat as Jews – subjected to hate speech that would be protected by law.
But consider what would happen if the government accedes to growing concern and drops the religious text defence.
If it then went ahead and expanded the scope of the scheme to cover religion, it would be very close to a traditional, and detestable, blasphemy law.
The only difference is that this time it would protect not just Christian churches but Islam and all other religions.
If that happens, how long would it be before people who might have benefited from the religious text defence are jailed for public “hate speech” criticising Islam’s approach to the rights of women, bigamy or its teachings about Jews?
Without the religious text defence, the question of whether critics of these aspects of Islam would finish up in jail would depend on three steps – all of which seem problematic.
The first step would require a judge to determine whether the criticism amounts to hate speech, and there is a wide range of judicial approaches on that question.
Former NSW chief justice Tom Bathurst has warned about the “imprecision and subjectivity” that would be part of a law that attempted to criminalise incitement to hate. That warning is outlined in a report published in September 2024 by the NSW Law Reform Commission.
The second step would require a judge to decide whether the criticism was intended to promote hatred of Muslims or – and this is where the real problem would arise – whether the criticism was intended to disseminate the idea that adherents of another faith have a superior approach to religion.
The third step is the test for liability which, if this bill is expanded to cover Islam, would largely depend on how Muslims felt about what was said about their religion.
If the test in the bill stays unchanged, the standards of the general community would be irrelevant.
Instead, a judge would be required to determine whether the criticism of Islam would cause a reasonable Muslim to be intimidated or to fear harassment, violence or to fear for their safety.
This focus on the standards of Muslims instead of the general community is in line with the way blasphemy laws once silenced critics of Christian churches.
In 1987, in a case known as Ogle v Strickland, the Federal Court explained that in order to be blasphemous, criticism of Christianity must be “so scurrilous and offensive as to pass the limits of decent controversy and to be calculated to outrage the feelings of any sympathiser with or believer in Christianity”.
There is clearly a need for laws that prevent the promotion of racial hatred in order to address the culture of Jew hatred that led to Bondi. But extending the reach of that law to criminalise other forms of speech is not justified.
The way forward is to drop the religious text defence, disavow plans to criminalise religious “hate speech” and redraft this bill as soon as possible


