Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
20 February, 2026
Islamic bodies seek to abolish hate speech laws yet jail those who criticise religion

With almost no public scrutiny, peak Islamic organisations have moved beyond trying to water down the definition of terrorism and now have a more ambitious agenda.

They are trying to abolish hate speech laws in NSW that they believe can be used in a discriminatory manner against those protesting against Israel.

And if they fail to achieve that goal, they want critics of Islam to be jailed for for up to two years for saying hateful things about their religion.

To be fair, the peak Islamic bodies believe in equal treatment. They want the same jail terms imposed on critics of all religions if their remarks are intended to incite religious hatred.

This proposal, which predates this week’s remarks about Muslims by Pauline Hanson, is outlined in a joint submission by nine peak Islamic bodies to a review of the NSW law criminalising incitement of racial hatred.

Yet even if that law, contained in section 93ZAA of the Crimes Act, were expanded beyond the subject of race to include statements about religion, Hanson would probably be on safe ground if she repeated her statement questioning whether there were any “good Muslims”.

For that, we can thank the High Court for inventing the implied freedom to engage in discussion about politics. But first, some background.

The report from that review of section 93ZAA, by former judge John Sackar, was presented to the NSW government before the December 14 terror attack on Bondi Beach. It has not been made public.

So it is not known whether Sackar and the NSW government like the idea of introducing what some might view as a form of blasphemy law.

All but two of the nine Islamic organisations seeking criminal penalties for inciting religious hatred were part of a coalition of Islamic groups that want the definition of terrorism in federal law to exclude attacks that are motivated by religion.

That proposal was sent to a review conducted last year by Jake Bright who is the federal government’s Independent National Security Legislation Monitor.

Bright’s researchers reviewed the outcomes of 83 terrorism cases and found that 95 per cent involved religion as at least one of the motives.

His report on the definition of terrorism, like the Sackar report, has not been made public.

The nine Islamic bodies are concerned that criminal penalties for inciting racial hatred could have a disproportionate impact on the fundamental freedoms of Muslims.

This, in their view, is due to excessive policing, the institutional conflation of Islam with terrorism, the fact that the definition of terrorism includes attacks that are religiously motivated, and the conflation of what they believe is legitimate political criticism of Israel and Zionism with hate speech.

It’s time for a reality check.

Zionism is support for Israel’s right to exist. Those who oppose Zionism are in fact declaring that Jews, because of their race and religion, do not deserve the right to self-determination in their historic homeland.

That is hate speech.

Now back to the Islamic proposal. If they are unable to secure the repeal of the criminal law against inciting racial hatred, they want NSW to jail those who incite hatred against Islam and other religions.

That deserves to go nowhere for the simple reason that such a law could easily run into constitutional difficulties. Even if it does not, it would have a chilling effect on political debate about Islam.

Speech about religion can have a political character and the right to engage in debate on political issues is protected by an implied constitutional freedom.

Pauline Hanson’s statement questioning if there were any “good Muslims” shows how a statement about religion can have a secondary and constitutionally protected character.

Hanson’s criticism of Muslims, while deeply offensive and wrong, was part of a broader statement about migration policy, terrorism and Islamic social practices – all of which are legitimate subjects for political debate.

Because of that, any criminal law that sought to jail Hanson for what she said would need to accept that she was entitled to make constitutionally protected statements about public policy regardless of whether those statements caused offence.

This is not a defence of Hanson. It is a statement of the law.

It is in line with the view of legal academic Mark Fowler who told Sackar’s review:

“I argue that the extension of section 93ZAA to religious vilification laws may be constitutionally invalid on the basis of the implied freedom of political communication.

“The implied freedom is potentially applicable because some religiously motivated communications which express religious teaching have a political dimension and are therefore a form of political communication,” Fowler wrote.

In 2006, Professor Nick Aroney of the University of Quensland wrote in the Federal Law Review that it is difficult to separate religious disagreement from political disagreement.

“It is doubtful whether we can draw an a priori line between political abuse and religious vilification,” he wrote.

That, according to Aroney, means that a law that prohibits religious vilification could, in at least some of its applications, amount to what the High Court has described as a “burden” on the implied constitutional freedom of political communication.

For the record, the organisations that want NSW to make this change are the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils, the Australian National Imams Council, the Lebanese Muslim Association, the Muslim Legal Network NSW, Muslim Votes Matter, the Muslim Women Association, the Shia Muslim Council of Australia and the Muslim Vote.