Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
26 September, 2025
Why some truck billboards in the US are an uncomfortable sign for Albanese’s coal stance

When Anthony Albanese was in New York this week trying to persuade Americans to invest in Australia, a truck emblazoned with a very different message was cruising the streets.

An electronic billboard that ran its full length carried this warning: “Australia paid the Chinese Communist Party but stiffed American investors.”

That truck, and another parked outside the White House in Washington, were reminders of an incident in 2014 in which the rule of law was set aside by NSW with little regard to the financial damage this imposed on Americans, or the international implications.

The mobile billboards – and Albanese’s pitch for US capital – have given American institutions and Donald Trump competing narratives about Australia.

In New York, Albanese said: “We are a great destination for capital.”

“We have all the things that you will be looking for if you are trying to make up what are the ideal attributes that make you an attractive investment destination,” he said.

As well as a “solid legal and political system” Australia had “a belief in free and fair trade and the rule of law”.

That amounts to a welcome recognition by the prime minister that the health of the rule of law is one of the factors that can attract capital to the projects he wants to encourage.

The logic is bullet-proof: the rule of law is much more than a requirement that the law should be obeyed. It is a doctrine underpinned by a set of principles, such as equal treatment under the law, that are designed to prevent arbitrary rule.

From the perspective of a foreign investor, it means capital will not be subject to arbitrary seizure and will be protected by rules that are known in advance and applied by independent courts.

Now compare that with the story behind those mobile billboards.

The billboards were organised by NuCoal Resources – a company with Australian and American shareholders that was stripped of an exploration licence, its main asset, by the then Liberal government of NSW.

That expropriation was put into effect by special legislation in 2014 that paid little regard to the principles of the rule of law. It sidelined that state’s normal mining law and extinguished property rights, common law rights and contractual rights.

NuCoal was never accused of wrongdoing and nobody associated with the company, past or present, has a conviction against their name.

The cancellation of its exploration licence caused the company’s share price to collapse which imposed massive losses on shareholders.

Americans owned 30 per cent of NuCoal which had a peak valuation of $400 million.

Here’s the problem that now confronts Albanese: While the expropriation was undertaken by NSW, the federal government is responsible for foreign treaties – including the US-Australia Free Trade Agreement.

NSW, under the Liberals, cancelled NuCoal’s licence without compensation or due process of law – which are key requirements of that treaty.

Those provisions, like the rule of law, were supposed to protect American investments from arbitrary seizure.

But for more than a decade successive federal governments, Labor and Coalition, have conducted themselves as though this treaty with the US can be ignored with impunity.

The obligations to the US that Australia has chosen to ignore are outlined in Article 11.7 of the Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement.

It says neither party may expropriate or nationalise an investment unless it is accompanied by prompt, adequate and effective compensation, and is done in accordance with due process of law.

On October 20, when Albanese is due to see Trump at the White House, nobody should be surprised if the prime minister is asked to explain why Australia has breached this treaty.

It would also be surprising if Trump fails to seek an explanation for the very different treatment of Chinese-owned assets.

In 2017 NSW paid $262 million to Chinese company Shenhua Watermark in order to reclaim 51.4 per cent of its exploration licence.

Albanese did not cause this problem, nor did NSW premier Chris Minns. The NuCoal expropriation is the toxic legacy of Barry O’Farrell, the former Liberal premier of NSW.

Yet Albanese is in the unfortunate position of attempting to drum up investment from America at precisely the time when the shameful treatment of American investors in NuCoal is gaining traction.

On September 5, Republican Congressman Joe Wilson raised this issue in a letter he sent to Jamieson Greer, the US Trade Representative.

“As you know, this case represents a textbook example of expropriation without compensation,” Wilson told Greer.

“Hundreds of thousands of American investors in NuCoal have been impacted by the cancelling of the project licence by the government of NSW, Australia, in 2014, and have never been provided due process to seek compensation . . .

“For a decade, these investors have watched as the NSW government compensated other companies – including Shenhua, a state-owned Chinese Communist Party mining company – while denying American investors the same treatment.

“It is incredibly alarming to see an allied nation paying its debts to the CCP but not to American citizens.

“I am a strong supporter of our alliance and partnership with Australia and want to see our trade agreement work effectively. To ensure the continued strength of that partnership, due process and compensation must be afforded to the investors in NuCoal,” Wilson wrote.

When Albanese sees Trump in the White House, NuCoal plans to roll out those mobile billboards once more so they can be seen not just by Trump, but by those who might be considering investing in this country.