In the aftermath of the attack on Helen Haines, public policy changes will prove to be inadequate unless we recognise the true nature of what happened.
The motives behind this attack will be determined by the justice system. But the practical impact is already apparent: Haines is an elected representative of the Australian state. She has suffered grievous, life-changing injuries in the service of this nation.
In that sense, what happened to this woman outside her Wangaratta electorate office was an attack on Australian democracy. We need to respond accordingly.
Much of the debate so far has focused on the need for greater civility in public life and more attention to the security of public officeholders.
Those ideas, while important, should not be allowed to divert attention from the real issue.
Democracy is under attack – here and in Europe. The French republic, progenitor of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, is in the grip of those who would do it harm.
If we are to avoid a similar rise in social alienation and political violence we need to win the battle of ideas that is now under way.
That will require far more robust recognition of the inspirational values at the heart of this democracy. The story of Australia’s democracy is worth telling: success against the odds, liberty emerging from servitude, equality of citizenship emerging from dispossession. And underpinning everything: the rule of law.
Political violence is the antithesis of democracy. Yet warning signs were staring us in the face long before Wangaratta and even before Islamic terrorists killed 15 people at Bondi Beach.
In November last year, just before the terrorist attack in December, the McKinnon organisation released a report that identified a startling level of support for political violence.
After surveying 4400 people around the nation, McKinnon found just 80.4 per cent rejected violence or extreme measures to advance causes.
That means almost 20 per cent of those surveyed did not reject extremism and political violence as a way of advancing their causes.
In January last year, the Albanese government’s own strategy for dealing with violent extremists warned that growing numbers of people were being quickly radicalised to violence.
In February last year, the Lowy Institute produced a policy brief warning that “sovereign citizens”, here and elsewhere, were promoting “delegitimising narratives” against democracies.
This country, and the rest of the Western world, is engaged in a civilisational struggle. And at least for now, democracies are on the back foot.
And the reason? Many of those in positions of authority, here and in other countries, have simply vacated the public square – cowed into silence or brainwashed into postcolonial guilt.
Democracy needs champions who are not afraid to speak their minds.
The most important of democratic values are civic equality and freedom of communication – ideas that give effect to the principle that the community, and not the government, is the ultimate source of power.
Governments are not there to control us. Citizens control them.
If we are serious about defending democracy, these are the ideas that need to be promoted – and not just in schools, but in migrant communities that might need assistance in understanding what it means to be part of a free society.
Blaming certain communities for failing to grasp civic equality is futile. We allowed them to join us. Their civic education is now our responsibility.
Those communities, like all of us, can learn much about democracy from Jonathan Sumption, a former judge of the UK Supreme Court. He wrote last year in his book, The Challenges of Democracy and the Rule of Law, that this system is a way of entrusting decision-making to people acceptable to the majority, whose power is defined and limited, and whose mandate is revocable.
He believes democracy can only work in a legal and social culture where there is freedom of thought, speech and association, uncontrolled access to reliable information and a large tolerance of political dissent.
Sumption endorsed the view of John Adams, the second president of the US, who warned that democracies failed from within.
They fail, according to Sumption, because people spontaneously turn to more authoritarian forms of government. This tendency can sometimes be found lurking inside initiatives that are supposed to protect us from harm.
It was apparent in the government’s draft Digital Duty of Care Bill that would have given a minister open-ended power to decide what information is harmful and therefore unlawful.
The latest version of this bill is much improved. But the goal is unchanged: it would still give a government official – and therefore the government – greater control of digital communications through vaguely defined new powers.
If freedom of communications is to be constrained, it should at least be done using legislation that is clear and specific so everyone knows where they stand.
That is not the case with the bill that is now before parliament.
Its core mechanism, in clause 26, is saddled with vague terms that are the antithesis of good lawmaking.
Online service providers, for example, would be required to take “appropriate” action to ensure a “safe” online environment by taking “effective” measures.
This scheme might be well intended but it leaves too much discretion over freedom of communication in the hands of government officials.
It would undermine one of the principles that makes democracy a superior system of government. And it would do so at the worst possible time.


