Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
25 September, 2026
Up goes Victorian youth crime but the government has handcuffed its own courts

For victims of crime in Victoria, next Wednesday is a date to remember: it marks the commencement of a law designed to make it harder for magistrates to order detention of dangerous young criminals.

This change, contained in section 324 of the Youth Justice Act, will inevitably expose Victoria to an increased risk of crime.

When that happens, responsibility will rest with state parliament – not the hapless judicial officers who from next week will be obliged to apply a law that disregards a threat to public safety.

The significance of this change can only be fully understood within the broader context of the youth justice system.

A report released this week says youth crime in Victoria surged by 40 per cent between 2022 and 2025.

That report, by the Victorian Auditor-General’s Office, found no evidence that the government’s youth crime prevention program, which has cost $40 million since 2016, is reducing youth crime.

Using youth crime figures from the Crime Statistics Agency, the report says: “The 2025 figure of 23,893 incidents is the highest since records began in 2016.”

It is against this background that the logic of Wednesday’s change to the Youth Justice Act needs to be assessed.

Section 324 will prevent the Children’s Court from ordering detention for some youth offenders who are a risk to community safety.

From Wednesday, those under the age of 14 who are convicted of lesser criminal offences can no longer be sentenced to detention – even if the Children’s Court believes they are a serious risk to community safety.

This court will be unable to order their detention unless they have been convicted of a handful of serious crimes that are listed in the act or some other serious or violent offence.

There are no good options here. The idea of detaining any child is abhorent – even in facilities designed for children.

But that is less abhorent than forcing judicial officers to impose non-custodial sentences on young criminals who are known to be a serious risk to public safety.

Yet that is what section 324 requires. Public safety has been sacrificed in order to keep dangerous young criminals out of detention.

This could have been avoided if the state government, then led by Jacinta Allan, had agreed to a Liberal Party suggestion and changed just one word of section 324.

On August 15, 2024, the Liberal Party’s David Davis tried to amend this provision so criminals who are a threat to society could be detained without the added requirement of a conviction for a serious or violent offence.

It would have meant changing the word “and” to “or”.

Had that change been made, detention could be ordered for young offenders who either commit serious offences, or who are proven to be a serious risk to the community.

By rejecting the Davis amendment, the government has guaranteed the community will be exposed to young criminals who are a risk to public safety.

This was not an oversight. Davis spelled out the problem in parliament:

“We want a stronger arrangement where ‘or’ is inserted there so that the court has the ability, where it does believe that the child presents a serious risk to the community, to impose a sentence of detention on that child,” he said.

“This is a very important point in the difference between the government and the opposition.

“We believe that the government’s approach with just a small number of very serious offences is too weak and has resulted in too much crime in the community,” he said.

The government’s Enver Erdogan, who was then minister for Youth Justice, was not for turning.

“The government will not be supporting the amendment. We think that the current bill reflects a considered approach focused on the most serious and high-harm offences,” Erdogan said.

Section 324 is part of a series of changes to the way Victoria deals with youth crime.

The age of criminal responsibility in that state was raised last year in order to give those under the age of 12 absolute immunity from the criminal law.

For those between the ages of 12 and 14 the doctrine of doli incapax gives them something that comes close to immunity.

They are presumed by this doctrine to be incapable of knowing their conduct was morally wrong.

And one of the fundamental requirements of criminal law is that without a guilty mind there can be no crime – regardless of whatever heinous act might have taken place.

The only way doli incapax can be overturned is if the prosecution can provide evidence that proves beyond reasonable doubt that a defendant knew their conduct was not simply naughty or mischievous but seriously wrong in a moral sense.

And it looks as though Victoria’s prosecutors are finding this extremely difficult.

On September 17, Children’s Court Magistrate Gail Hubble asked a prosecutor if he knew of any cases in the past two years where the prosecution had successfully rebutted the doli incapax presumption when the accused person was aged 12.

According to a report in the Herald-Sun, Hubble answered her own question: “I can – there are none.”

Here’s where things stand: In every other state the age of criminal responsibilty is 10, not 12 as in Victoria where youth crime is booming.

Those between 12 and 14 in Victoria have the benefit of doli incapax and even if that is overcome, section 324 will now ensure some dangerous young criminals will never be detained.