Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
1 May, 2026
High Court doctrine stalls Premier’s push to ban ‘intifada’ protest slogan

Last month’s research paper from the Australian National University showing patchy support for democracy should be compulsory reading for the judges of the High Court.

These judges, not their subordinates in the state courts, are the only judicial officers capable of addressing the most persistent current threat to the effectiveness of our democratic institutions.

That threat is a doctrine invented by the High Court 34 years ago when Australia was a very different country: the implied constitutional freedom of political communication.

The practical impact of this doctrine on contemporary Australia has been to strike down and delay parliamentary attempts to respond to those seeking to intimidate and threaten Jews with violence.

NSW premier Chris Minns made this clear on Tuesday when he said he would not legislate to outlaw calls to “globalise the intifada” unless the High Court first approved a similar law in Queensland.

“If the ban is upheld in Queensland, I’ll do it in NSW. I won’t hesitate,” Minns told Ben Fordham on radio 2GB.

The premier’s caution comes after the implied freedom led to defeat for his earlier attempts to address the upheaval in society since the invasion of Israel on October 7, 2023.

His reluctance to again be defeated in court is understandable. But, the delay in addressing this problem does little to restore faith in the effectiveness of our democratic institutions.

And the reason for the delay is the implied freedom.

It’s important to be clear about what “globalise the intifada” means – and the nature of the plan now on hold because of the High Court’s doctrine.

In January, the NSW Legislative Assembly produced a report that found the word “intifada” is used to describe periods of Palestinian protest and uprising against Israel, including the second intifada, which was characterised by violence.

“The slogan ‘globalise the intifada’ may therefore be perceived to incite violence against Jewish people on a broader scale,” that report says.

It called for the chanting of this phrase in a public place to be made unlawful – but only in certain circumstances.

It recommended including “a causal element” that links the use of the phrase with a particular material harm, such as incitement of hatred or harassment, intimidation or violence.

That inquiry did what it was supposed to do: it proposed a law that balanced freedom of communication against the legitimate goal of preventing wrongdoers from using these words to incite hatred, harassment, intimidation or violence.

If our democracy were working efficiently, this sensible balance would already be law.

But, the Minns government is sitting on its hands, cowed into inaction by its defeats in the NSW Supreme Court which, like every other court, is obliged to apply a doctrine that appears nowhere in the written text of the constitution.

Is it any wonder parts of the community have lost faith in the ability of democratic institutions to do their job?

Researchers at ANU have found that support for democracy is “fragile” among the young, particularly those without post-school qualifications.

“Fragile” is a massive understatement. Fewer than one in four of those aged 18 to 34 without year 12 or post-school qualifications believe democracy is always preferable.

That research, by Nicholas Biddle and Matthew Gray, suggests the reasons for this are not just educational disadvantage and economic insecurity, but low trust in the nation’s institutions.

That lack of institutional trust could be due to any number of factors.

But, there can be little doubt that the implied freedom has made it extremely difficult to trust that any government can provide a lasting response to those calling for an uprising against Jews.

Until the High Court has a change of mind and winds back this doctrine – or at least gives it some predictability – nobody can be certain that laws designed to prevent the intimidation of these Australians will survive.

Consider the recent history of the implied freedom: on October 16, at the request of the Palestine Action Group, the NSW Supreme Court struck down part of a law enacted in February last year, the Crimes Amendment (Places of Worship) Act, that protected the right of people to practise their religion free from intimidation.

Police were stripped of the power to issue move-on orders to those taking part in unauthorised protests and processions in proximity to places of worship.

On April 16, the Palestine Action Group and others relied on the implied freedom to persuade the Court of Appeal to strike down the temporary restrictions on street protests that had been enacted by Minns after fifteen people died in the Bondi terror attack.

Freedom of communication, like all other rights, is not absolute. Someone must balance it against other conflicting rights.

Nowhere in the text of the Constitution is the High Court given authority to override parliaments on this issue.

In 2018, legal academic Jeffrey Goldsworthy wrote that judges are surely bound not only by the goals of the framers of the Constitution but also by the means they chose to achieve those goals.

“That is why it has been said that the framers’ decisions about what to omit from the Constitution are entitled to as much respect as their decisions about what to include,” Goldsworthy wrote in “The Invisible Constitution in Comparative Perspective”.

“Otherwise a constitution is just a set of abstract objectives, which the judges can choose to implement in any way they think fit with no limit to the implications they can purport to find.”