Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
5 March, 2026
How Australia’s online safety watchdog has silenced free speech

Research by the Australian National University showing a slide in support for democracy among the young will leave many people scrambling for an explanation.

Here’s one: the lawless conduct of the federal government’s eSafety Commission.

This organisation’s behaviour – as revealed on February 18 by the Full Federal Court – came too late to be included in the ANU research paper on democracy that was made public this week.

But the court’s judgement shows in the clearest possible manner that one of the most important requirements of democratic governance is not working when it comes to the way this commission has been censoring social media.

In theory, the Online Safety Act and the eSafety Commission are supposed to give effect to the desire of parliament to prevent cyber abuse – which is a perfectly reasonable policy goal for any democracy.

This required a careful balancing of conflicting goals: the right to free speech and the right to be free from cyber abuse.

But remember, that is the role of parliament, not unelected bureaucrats.

For any type of censorship to have democratic legitimacy, the eSafety Commission and its employees need to give effect to the law that was approved by parliament – not their personal preferences.

For democratic governance to work, society must be able to trust that the agencies of the executive branch of government are applying the laws enacted by parliament.

But how can anyone trust what the eSafety Commission says now it is clear that its officials have been have restricted freedom of communication in ways that are not authorised by the laws enacted by parliament?

Without a full accounting of the extent of this problem, it is difficult to see how trust in this agency can be restored.

When parliament enacted the Online Safety Act it did not want the eSafety Commission to be some sort of ayatollah of online morality, free to roam the internet and strike down anything it does not like.

Instead, parliament weighed the conflicting goals and gave the commission limited authority to order the removal of postings on social media that meet a tight definition of “cyber-abuse”.

That definition means a reasonable person would conclude the material in question was intended to cause serious harm. It must also be menacing, harassing or offensive.

Mere offence, without the intent to cause serious harm, is not enough – which is just as well because reasonable minds will differ on whether particular statements are offensive.

The Online Safety Act makes it clear that the commission is not empowered to strike down online content that merely triggers ordinary emotional reactions such as distress, grief, fear or anger.

But on February 18, the Full Federal Court handed down a judgement showing the eSafety Commission sought the removal of material from social media that it knew was outside the definition of cyber abuse.

The material in question was a posting by children’s rights activist Celine Baumgarten who complained about “queer theory” being taught to primary school children in Melbourne.

The Full Federal Court unanimously upheld a ruling by the Administrative Decisions Tribunal that had sided with Baumgarten.

This affair has unmasked a pattern of behaviour in which the commission has been using informal tactics to interfere in communications.

The evidence in the Baumgarten case shows the commission had sent just three or four formal removal notices to social media providers in the past year.

But it had sent “a few hundred” informal complaint alerts including the alert that prompted the removal of Baumgarten’s post outlining her concern about the teaching of “queer theory” to children.

Remember, the commission knew Baumgarten’s post was not cyber abuse.

Without a full accounting of all the other informal complaint alerts that were sent by the commission we might never know how many of those “few hundred” matters were also outside the commission’s jurisdiction.

We might never know, in other words, how much unjustified damage this agency has inflicted on freedom of communication.

The only positive development for democracy is that this affair has shown that another fundamental doctrine – responsible government – is in good health.

Ministers and their officials – who are all part of the executive branch of government – are responsible to parliament for their conduct.

It has therefore been gratifying to see Sarah Henderson, the Coalition’s communications spokeswoman, hold the commission to account.

“The online safety of all Australians is incredibly important, but in recent times we have seen a number of decisions by the eSafety Commissioner that I would suggest are really a bridge too far” Henderson told the Senate on Wednesday.

“They are really stepping into the area of stifling free speech, and that is a fundamental right of every single Australian.”

Henderson’s assessment is in line with that of legal academic Janina Broughey of the University of NSW.

In an important article for Australian Public Law, Professor Broughey writes that the Baumgarten case “reveals that the commission has gone beyond its statutory mandate by working to limit online speech that it considers harmful or otherwise problematic but that falls below the threshold set in the statute”.

The Online Safety Act provides guidance for the commission’s employees on what they can and cannot do.

Instead of doing what parliament wanted, this agency has eroded freedom of communication and damaged public trust in an agency of the federal government.

All around us, free societies are under threat. If we are to defeat the challenge to democratic governance, we need to get our own house in order.