Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
26 February, 2026
Press Council missed crucial legal truth in Drumgold ruling

When it comes to legal ethics Shane Drumgold SC refuses to accept the reality of his position. And so, it seems, does the Press Council.

It might seem surprising that a well known silk like Drumgold would choose the Press Council and not the justice system to settle an argument with The Australian about a report that impugns his professional conduct.

But Drumgold had good reason for steering clear of the courts.

The Press Council is a non-court, with little or no legal expertise – certainly not enough to match wits on the law with a former Director of Public Prosecutions for the ACT.

The Press Council’s rules also make it clear that complainants and media organisations are not usually allowed to be represented at full adjudications by lawyers or other professional representatives.

That might seem fair. But how fair is it when the complainant is a silk and the argument is, at its core, a dispute about the proper interpretation of a legal ruling about the silk’s own conduct?

Lawyers for The Australian wrote to the Press Council on November 27 complaining about what they described as a lack of procedural fairness in its handling of the Drumgold matter.

“In addition, we reiterate (yet again) the procedural unfairness of our client not being able to be represented and having to present against an SC on matters that ultimately turn on a legal point. This is patently unfair,” wrote Justin Quill of law firm Thomson Geer.

Drumgold’s path to the Press Council began two years ago when he failed to overturn a report by Walter Sofronoff KC containing adverse findings about his conduct during Bruce Lehrmann’s aborted criminal trial.

Drumgold had been prosecuting Lehrmann on charges of raping Brittany Higgins but the trial was stopped because of juror misconduct – leaving the issue of criminal guilt or innocence unresolved.

While Sofronoff’s review of the Lehrmann prosecution was declared to be tainted by an apprehension of bias, the Supreme Court of the ACT did not quash the report, nor did it declare it unlawful.

It ruled that seven of Sofronoff’s eight damning findings about Drumgold were not legally unreasonable.

Drumgold won on the issue of apprehended bias and on two other points.

But he failed on the issues that really mattered – the seven damning findings about his conduct.

Drumgold had asked the court to declare that all of the Sofronoff report, or at least those parts that related to him, were invalid, of no effect or unlawful.

The judge declined to do so.

So if Sofronoff’s report has not been declared unlawful and seven of its damning findings are not legally unreasonable, where does that leave Drumgold?

He won a declaration that the report is tainted by an apprehension of bias, as opposed to the reality of bias, because of Sofronoff’s extensive contact during his inquiry with Janet Albrechtsen, a columnist with The Australian.

But this falls well short of what he wanted: a declaration that the Sofronoff report, or those parts that relate to him, are invalid, of no effect or unlawful.

Yet when Drumgold complained to the Press Council about The Australian’s coverage of Justice Kaye’s decision, he actually said the judge’s decision meant he had been “entirely successful” in his legal action over the Sofronoff report.

Drumgold’s complaint, dated October 1, 2024, says: “In legal terms, the application for the declarations in the matter of Drumgold v Board of Inquiry & Ors was entirely successful in achieving all it sought to achieve, being a declaration vitiating all adverse findings and comments against me, just not by all the means sought.”

In Drumgold’s view, as outlined in his complaint, the actual state of the law was that “all of the Sofronoff findings were declared unlawful” by virtue of Justice Kaye’s ruling on bias.

The declarations issued by Justice Kaye on March 4, 2024, are a matter of public record. The Press Council’s determination is silent about whether it looked up what those orders actually say.

Had it done so, it would have noticed that the judge’s order relating to bias does not say that the Sofronoff report, or those parts dealing with Drumgold, are unlawful. Nor does it say that the seven findings about Drumgold’s conduct are unlawful or legally unreasonable.

Drumgold, however, told the Press Council that the effect of the order on bias is to render all of the Sofronoff findings unlawful.

Consider what that would mean.

Justice Kaye declined Drumgold’s request to issue a declaration stating that Sofronoff’s findings were unlawful. But according to Drumgold, the judge then issued a declaration about bias containing a hidden meaning that is equivalent to the order the judge declined to issue.

But there’s more. On May 8 last year Drumgold told a Press Council adjudication panel that Albrechtsen had been the subject of an adverse finding.

This prompted a written protest from The Australian pointing out that at no stage had Albrechtsen been the subject of any adverse finding – either by Justice Kaye or by the ACT Integrity Commission, which had also examined this affair.

“We are concerned that Mr Drumgold would make such a serious allegation without any factual basis,” wrote Darren Davidson, the newspaper’s managing editor.

“We invite the panel to draw an adverse inference against Mr Drumgold for his conduct in making such a blatantly false allegation,” Davidson wrote.

The Press Council’s ruling against The Australian, which the newspaper is obligated to publish, repeats Drumgold’s original claim that “all of the Sofronoff findings were declared unlawful by Justice Kay by virtue of the finding of apprehended bias”.

In response, The Australian accepted that the finding of apprehended bias applies to all Sofronoff’s findings, but it said it did not follow that the findings had therefore been overturned, nor did it preclude the findings from being upheld.

In November, when Quill wrote to the Press Council on behalf of The Australian, he pointed out that the Press Council “is being effectively asked to determine legal questions rather than matters of journalism”.

“That shift has occurred because Mr Drumgold has framed the dispute almost entirely around his own incorrect interpretation of Justice Kaye’s judgement,” Quill wrote.

In order to ensure the Press Council was properly informed, Quill provided legal opinions on the Kaye judgement from two of the nation’s most senior silks, Matt Collins KC and William Houghton KC.

He included a statutory declaration in which he says only two silks were consulted and no attempt had been made to seek multiple opinions so the favourable one could be selected.

Houghton wrote that the Justice Kaye’s ruling meant the seven instances of misconduct by Drumgold “still stand”.

“They have not been overturned or set aside,” he wrote.

Collins wrote that Justice Kaye “seems to me to have come to the view that not only were Mr Sofronoff’s findings not legally unreasonable, they were objectively correct” on seven of the eight findings of misconduct.

“Put crisply, the judgement is therefore far from a vindication for Mr Drumgold,” he wrote.

“While it is obviously damaging to the reputation of Mr Sofronoff, in that he has been found to have engaged in conduct such as would give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias on the part of a fair-minded observer, Mr Drumgold now wears the consequences of a decision of the ACT Supreme Court which, in substance, upheld as objectively correct a series of very damaging findings of fact about his professional reputation,” Collins wrote.

The Press Council’s determination shows no evidence that it grappled with the assessments of Collins and Houghton.

Had it done so, it might have thought twice before making a determination that opens the door for disgruntled litigants to use the Press Council as a rough and ready court of last resort.

As for Drumgold, the Press Council’s determination does not remove the taint of those seven adverse findings. It does not change what Justice Kaye decided.

For lawyers, who are sworn officers of the court, the most serious finding is that Drumgold made false statements and knowingly lied to the ACT Supreme Court.

This is closely followed by the finding that he asked a solicitor to swear a misleading affidavit and, when that lawyer declined to do so, he preyed on a junior lawyer’s inexperience and required that lawyer to swear to the truth of the misleading affidavit.