Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
27 March, 2026
The High Court rulings that have created a constitutional turf war with government over powers

One of the great fictions about Australia democracy is that the Constitution can only be changed if a referendum wins support from a majority of the people in a majority of the states.

There is another way – one that relies on the fact that the Constitution means what the High Court says it means.

So when the judges change their minds about something important, we should pay attention.

Yet over the past three years there has been far too little scrutiny, as the court has used this secondary method to impose a major shift in one of our most important constitutional doctrines: the separation of powers.

The boundary between the role of the judiciary, and the role of government ministers and their officials has changed. And if last week’s High Court decision is any guide, the government’s lawyers are struggling to come to terms with the new reality.

That decision, known as EGH19, is the latest in a string of defeats for the government over its attempts to protect the community from foreign criminals who are in this country unlawfully.

It’s worth considering why the government has been losing.

It’s not because the judges have developed a fondness for foreign crooks. It’s because the Albanese government, through no fault of its own, has been caught up in the court’s changing approach to the separation of powers.

On one level, those cases were all about the Albanese government’s attempts to detain, monitor and control the movement of criminals who had no lawful right to be here but, for various reasons, could not be deported.

But that misses the real story. What we are witnessing is a turf war between the two great centres of constitutional power: the judiciary and the executive.

Those immigration cases provide the clearest evidence that the boundary between the role of the judiciary and the role of the executive branch of government has shifted in favour of the judiciary.

This shift has placed the Albanese government at an incredible disadvantage; one that will be felt by all future federal governments unless the court reverses direction.

It means procedures for dealing with foreign criminals that were once on the government’s side of the boundary are now considered by the court to be illegitimate unless they are applied by the judiciary.

There was a time, for example, when it was considered perfectly acceptable for the executive branch of government – ministers and their officials – to indefinitely detain foreign criminals if they were in this country unlawfully and could not be deported.

That changed in 2023 in a decision known as NZYQ which overturned the High Court’s previous endorsement of this practice and led to the release of criminals into the community.

Since then, the government has twice attempted to use the powers of the executive branch to protect the community from these people.

Defeats followed in the 2024 decision known as YBFZ and again in last week’s ruling in EGH19.

The problem is that all of the government’s tactics – indefinite detention, ankle bracelets with monitoring devices and curfews – were struck down by the High Court as punitive regardless of the government’s assertions that they are designed to protect the community.

Under our system of government, parliament makes the laws, governments administer those laws but only the judiciary has the authority to impose punishments for breaches of the law.

The Albanese government and its successors need certainty about the court’s new approach so they can determine which government practices are now vulnerable to being struck down as punitive.

Last week’s ruling in EGH19 muddied the waters. It struck down the latest regulation imposing ankle bracelets and curfews. But the seven judges produced six separate judgments that ran to 153 pages, including the two dissents.

There is clear evidence that the court’s new approach to the separation of powers has become a source of unhappiness among some judges.

In last year’s ruling in a case known as Ravbar, Justice James Edelman wrote that he would attempt to “make the best sense of and to apply” the test for punitive action that had been used in NZYQ and later in YBFZ.

“But with great respect, the state of the present jurisprudence concerning the concept of punishment in Chapter III of the Constitution (which concerns the judicial power) is extremely difficult to understand or apply and involves a legal fiction,” he wrote.

“The test is essentially that a legislative means is ‘punitive’ if it is prima facie punitive, unless a court concludes that it is not punitive because it is not for a punitive purpose.”

Others might describe the test as subjective and therefore unpredictable.

In last week’s decision in EGH19, Justice Edelman was part of the majority but his judgment contained this warning: “This court should not be hoodwinked by the sophistry of a strict separation between the concept of ‘punishment’ and that of ‘protection’ … it is a fundamental category error to treat protection and punishment as entirely independent categories.”

Another judge, Simon Steward, dissented in EGH19 after pointing out that the ruling in YBFZ “marked a notable shift in this court’s chapter III jurisprudence”.

“But while I continue to consider that this new chapter III jurisprudence is not supported by the Constitution, I am bound to apply it,” Justice Steward wrote.

It might take a new generation of judges for the court to change course. Justices Edelman and Steward have time on their side. They are not due to retire until 2044 and 2039 respectively.