From a rule of law perspective, vague laws of the kind that are increasingly popular in Canberra are worse than no law at all.
They harm the innocent by failing to provide adequate warning against conduct that can incur liability.
They open the door to arbitrary enforcement and they inhibit individual liberty by forcing people to conduct their affairs with a timidity that has no place in a free society.
Vague laws are a direct attack on the idea that people should be free to conduct their affairs in any manner they choose so long as they remain within the bounds of the law.
Yet that concept breaks down when governments abandon legislative precision and leave the boundaries of the law uncertain.
In several unrelated fields that is exactly what is happening in the national capital.
In the field of taxation, key aspects of the legislation that gives effect to the government’s budget are dependent on ministerial discretion.
If enacted, this legislation would give the government the right at some later date to change the type of assets and individuals who are affected by its overhaul of capital gains tax.
That makes it impossible for parliament to make an informed decision about whether these changes deserve to become law.
The effect of such a law is predictable: it would entrench uncertainty about the scope of capital gains tax and the likely return on investment.
If the goal is to encourage an investment strike, this is how you do it.
That, however, is nowhere near as objectionable as the government’s plan to overhaul federal secrecy laws.
It plans to insert a vague new offence in the Commonwealth Criminal Code that would send people to prison for conduct that is impossible to determine in advance.
People would be jailed for using government information in an “improper” way – whatever that means.
That term has been left undefined in proposed changes to the Criminal Code which has triggered concerns from the media industry, the Law Council of Australia, the Human Rights Law Centre and the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.
Their concerns are outlined in submissions to the senate’s legal and constitutional affairs committee which is examining the government’s Secrecy Provisions Amendment (Repealing Offences) Bill.
It would replace some nondisclosure offences, but the Law Council believes the proposed new offence has a broader application “and is not satisfactorily clear in terms of the scope of conduct intended to be criminalised”.
“It contains vague and uncertain terminology and is not clearly directed towards protecting information of a sufficiently grave nature where disclosure would have sufficiently grave consequences,” the Law Council said.
“The rule of law requires that the law must be certain and clear – that is, on the face of the primary legislation itself.”
Australia’s Right to Know coalition, which represents the media industry, has a similar view.
“The offence uses fundamentally indeterminate criteria (criminalising ‘improper’ disclosures),” the ARTK told the inquiry.
“This makes assessing whether or not a given disclosure of information is criminalised ahead of time impossible and so fundamentally undermines the rule of law and free speech,” it says.
The adverse impact of this vague wording would not be confined to journalists and their sources within the federal bureaucracy.
The risk of criminal liability would also have a chilling effect on private sector organisations that receive government information during consultations over proposed legal changes.
This risk has been highlighted by the Human Rights Law Centre.
“The provision as drafted risks raising a spectre of criminal liability in civil society engagement and government consultation processes and as a result risks that persons will be discouraged from or altogether stop engaging with the Commonwealth, particularly on a voluntary basis,” the Human Rights Law Centre said.
The Law Council warned that the current drafting “adds significant uncertainty by risking possible criminal sanction following unpaid advice, consultation or discussion between civil society and a Commonwealth entity”.
According to the Australian Strategic Policy Institute the decision to leave the term “improper” undefined “creates uncertainty for officials, contractors, advisers, service providers and prosecutors operating around government information”.
This resort of vague drafting is becoming a bad habit in Canberra.
On May 26, the government published an issues paper about its proposed “digital duty of care” for online service providers that seems to be the fallback for its failed attempt to outlaw misinformation and disinformation.
Social media organisations, who are the main targets of this initiative, deserve little sympathy. Much of what they publish belongs in a sewer.
But even they deserve to know precisely what conduct is unlawful in Australia.
Instead, the online duty of care descends into the same vagueness and potential for subjectivity that led to criticism of the misinformation and disinformation scheme.
The latest proposal would impose a statutory duty for online services to provide a “safe” environment and prevent the dissemination of illegal or “harmful” material.
Legislating against material that causes “harm” would impose unknowable limits on public discourse.
Would the promotion of bushwalking in areas that are contested by Indigenous activists be suppressed as harmful?
Would graziers be prevented from promoting their produce because some public servant considers red meat to be harmful?
Under the government’s plan, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant would make binding rules outlawing the dissemination of “categories of harm”.
Just like the missing details on capital gains tax, the eSafety’s commissioner’s determinations would be disallowable instruments capable of being overturned by parliament – but without the scrutiny that accompanies legislation.


