In the three years in which Jews have been pilloried in the public square, this country has changed. And not in a good way.
Overall, Australian democracy is still on a solid footing. But there are now signs that the surge in anti-semitism, left relatively unaddressed for too long, has damaged the fabric of society.
There is a real risk this country, which prides itself on being the land of the fair go, is in the grip of social decline.
Many are now fearful of speaking their minds as violence becomes more acceptable and civil discourse falls victim to the tyrrany of identity politics.
In these circumstances, nobody should be surprised by surveys showing trust in the federal government, the supposed guardian of our liberties, has collapsed.
Evidence of social decline is to be found in this week’s McKinnon Index and two other reports – one from the Scanlon Foundation Research Institute and the other from Jillian Segal, the federal government’s envoy on anti-semitism.
The bottom line is we are paying the price for allowing imported hatreds from the Middle East to infect our leading cultural institutions.
The three reports identify different aspects of the decline.
But when they are read together the picture is clear: sone of the most vulnerable Australians have been led down a path to alienation and support for violence.
Others have been cowed into silence – afraid to speak up on politics.
McKinnon has identified a huge increase in support for violence – particularly among the young – and a sharp decline in the proportion of people in all age groups who believe they can no longer freely express political opinions.
After surveying more than 4000 people, McKinnon found the proportion of men and women who believe they can speak freely about politics has collapsed when compared to last year.
McKinnon is right to warn this is just one year’s figures. But the scale of the decline suggests freedom of political communication is in serious trouble.
For men aged 18 to 24 the collapse in the proportion who believe they enjoy political free speech has been immense: down from 72.6 per cent to just 49.9 per cent this year.
For women in that age cohort, the collapse was almost as bad: down from 63.7 per cent last year to just 49.8 per cent.
The decline in free speech was not as sharp in other age groups but the pattern was the same: people believe they have less freedom to express political opinions than they did last year.
So what could be causing this great silencing?
Segal has no doubt that when it comes to the spread of what she describes as “progressive anti-Semitism”, the blame lies with purveyors of elite opinion at universities and cultural institutions.
“This has created environments where certain views, particularly those held by the overwhelming majority of Jews in relation to Israel or Zionism, are unacceptable and anyone holding such views is equally unacceptable,” Segal writes in her latest report.
Just this week, the SBS Ombudsman found that the public broadcaster was wrong to assert that the International Court of Justice “had found it plausible that Israel is committing genocide” when the court had made no such finding.
Just as worrying is the rise in support for violence and the sharp decline in the proportion of people who trust the federal government.
The proportion of men between the ages of 18 and 24 who believe violence is sometimes justified has jumped in one year from 19.3 per cent to 27.5 per cent.
Support for violence rose in every age cohort of men, but by smaller amounts.
On trust, the Scanlon Foundation Research Institute found the proportion of adults who believe the federal government can be trusted to do the right thing almost always or most of the time declined from 54 per cent in 2020 to just 31 per cent.
This is broadly in line with McKinnon which found just 33.1 per cent of the community trusts the government – down 4.5 points in a year
These reports, when read together, present a policy quandary for the government.
Support for violence is rising, trust in the government has collapsed and significant numbers of people believe they are no longer as free to express political opinions.
Freedom of political communication is one of the most fundamental of all democratic freedoms. So now is the time to protect that freedom, not restrict it.
If the goal is to restore trust and protect our democracy, this cannot be the right time to impose new restrictions on freedom of communications through the government’s Digital Duty of Care Bill.
Even if this bill were perfect – which it is not – there is a less harmful way of arresting the social decline that now confronts this country.
During the week, my organisation, the Rule of Law Education Centre, pointed to shortcomings and proposed changes to the national civics and citizenship assessment for school students. Click here for media release.
At the moment, only some schools are covered by this test, and even then it is only required every three years.
That makes it almost impossible for governments to identify schools that need to work harder to explain concepts like equality before the law and equality of citizenship.
The young need help in the fight against “progressive anti-semitism”.
So why not make civics and citizenship a mandatory priority area for every school that is examined every year?


