Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
2 October, 2026
Flawed laws and failing civics education expose Australia to rising post-October 7 hatred

Next Wednesday, October 7, marks the anniversary of two very different failures of public policy.

In Israel, the 2023 invasion by Hamas made it clear that deterrence alone was not enough to protect that country from its enemies.

In Australia, October 7 marked the start of a radical attack on the idea that everyone, regardless of race or religion, is entitled to equal protection of the law.

For three years Jews and those who support Israel’s right to exist have been hounded from Australia’s public square and subjected to campaigns of hate and discrimination that culminated in mass murder at Bondi Beach.

Yet civic equality is one of the core principles that underpin the rule of law. It stands at the heart of true democracies.

What we are confronting is a failure of our own making.

In two of the great spheres of public policy – law and education – our response to the wave of Jew hatred and violence since October 7 has been shamefully inadequate.

The last three years have shown conclusively that the law alone is incapable of dealing with the malaise that has turned our universities and public places into forums for incitement of hate and violence.

Prosecutions, when compared to the avalanche of anti-semitic hate, have been rare.

At least some of the blame must rest with a doctrine invented by the High Court in 1992 when Australia was a very different place.

That doctrine – the implied constitutional freedom of political communication – has frustrated attempts by NSW to reclaim public places from those who have intimidated and silenced Jews.

Even if the High Court reforms this doctrine and provides greater certainty for state governments, legal action is, by definition, a reaction to misconduct that has already taken place.

If the goal is to reverse the wave of hatred we need to address the sickness within our culture.

And that requires far more intensive efforts on civic education – not just in the schools but among those who seek to become permanent residents and citizens.

One of the Jewish community’s great defenders, NSW Labor’s Ron Hoenig, has made the point that the entire country has a stake in this issue.

“At what point did the intolerable become something we simply became accustomed to?” he said in a statement issued this week on social media.

“Because hatred does not begin and become dangerous only when someone picks up a weapon. It becomes dangerous when words and slogans are repeated so often that we stop asking what they mean – when intimidation is excused, when abuse is rationalised, and when each new boundary crossed makes the next one easier to cross.”

What has happened to this country since October 7 is largely due to our own naivety.

Civic equality is so fundamental to our way of life we simply assumed it came naturally to everyone.

Other countries go to great efforts to entrench their core beliefs but our efforts have fallen short of what the times require.

The clearest evidence of this can be seen in the inabiity of most school students to grasp the basic requirements of civics and citizenship.

In 2024, just 43 per cent of year six students across the country were proficient in civics and citizenship. When year 10 students were assessed, just 28 per cent were proficient.

Those figures are from the report of the National Assessment Program for Civics and Citizenship which is produced every three years by the Australian Curriculum Assessment and Reporting Authority.

Now consider the positions of migrants.

This country accepts permanent residents and new citizens from all parts of the globe including those regions where democracy and the rule of law are unknown.

While all migrants are subject to the same rules, the reality is that not all migrants have the same needs when it comes to learning what it means to be a citizen or even a permanent resident.

By failing to provide enough information about democracy to those who need it, we are doing ourselves no favours.

Just this week we learned that more than 30,000 people who arrived illegally by boat during the Rudd-Gillard era have been granted permanent visas.

Holders of these visas were required to sign a document acknowledging Australian values and after two years they are entitled to apply for citizenship. When that happens, they are required to pass a test that is less than rigorous.

It consists of 20 multiple choice questions including five on Australian values that must be answered correctly. Multiple attempts are permitted.

If the goal is to produce citizens who embrace Australian values, this cohort – who have ignored our migration laws – will require more attention and help.

But so do all those who arrive in this country from places where democracy and civic equality are unknown. It’s in our interest to promote these ideas.

In January last year a parliamentary inquiry into civics education heard evidence that the citizenship test did not provide meaningful depth in civics for “culturally and linguistically diverse” (CALD) people.

That inquiry, by the Joint Select Committee on Electoral Matters, accepted evidence from several migrant groups and concluded more extensive civics education is needed.

“While there is a range of government-supported, community-run programs focused on settlement and citizenship, in-depth and ongoing civics education should be provided to CALD communities outside electoral events and after initial settlement,” says the committee’s report.

If the past three years have taught us anything, it’s this: The time for complacency is over.