One of the most significant anniversaries in the life of this nation – and every other free society – has just come and gone with barely a mention.
That anniversary marks the birth in the modern world of an idea that is now ingrained in Australia: freedom under the law.
This mindset predated Federation. It also predated the American Declaration of Independence. The Americans fought a revolution precisely because their pre-existing freedoms had come under threat.
In both countries freedom under the law means everyone is subject to the law – particularly governments and their officials.
We have chosen different ways of giving effect to this idea but the goal in both countries is the same: the power of government is constrained by law and the liberty of the citizen is defined by law.
That is why laws must be clear. Without clear drafting the boundaries of our freedom of action depend not on democratically enacted laws, but on the whims of politicians and officials.
Vague laws are antithetical to freedom under the law.
So where did this idea that law limits power come from?
Some look to the influence of Judaeo-Christian principles that are found in the Bible.
Deuteronomy 17:18, for example, requires rulers, and not just the ruled, to obey the law. It says the King of Israel is to write out a copy of God’s law, keep it nearby, read from it all his life and faithfully obey the law.
But for us, and the Americans, one of the greatest sources of our freedom from tyrannical government was a quarrel that was settled 811 years ago in an English meadow at Runnymede, about 30 kilometres from London.
On June 15 in the year 1215 England’s King John struck a deal with rebellious barons and set down the terms of their bargain in a document known as the Great Charter, Magna Carta.
Former prosecutor Nicholas Cowdery has written that the contemporary strength of Magna Carta is its status as the foundation of the rule of law.
“It is said to show that no person – not even a King – is above the law,” Cowdery wrote in a book edited by the late Robin Speed, co-founder of the Rule of Law Institute, marking the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta.
The contributors to that book included Robert French, a former Chief Justice of the High Court, as well as Virginia Bell, also formerly of the High Court and now presiding over the royal commission into anti-semitism and social cohesion.
Jim Spigelman, a former Chief Justice of NSW, was also a contributor to Speed’s book, The Magna Carta in Australia.
Spigelman wrote that the long-term significance of the Great Charter did not lie in its status as a sacred text because almost all of the original references concerned matters that are now irrelevant.
He wrote that its real significance lies in its underlying themes that were further developed over centuries of English constitutional history.
“It is by no means clear how much actually ‘started’ at Runnymede, and how much was simply confirmed,” Spigelman wrote.
One of the Charter’s core themes was that King John was obliged to consult what Spigelman referred to as “the political nation” on important issues.
The clearest contemporary expression of this idea is the Westminster principle of responsible government – that governments are responsible to parliament for their actions.
When ministers and their officials are forced at senate estimates hearings to explain their conduct that process is the legacy of Magna Carta.
The Charter marked a turning point in the limitation of arbitrary power, not just in medieval England, but in all free societies.
The ideas of due process, a fair trial and equality before the law can all be traced back to the themes that were present in Magna Carta.
But the Charter was not the only source of these concepts. The influence of Judaeo-Christian principles on the Charter and on our liberties cannot be ignored.
It could be argued, for example, that equality before the law can also be traced back to Leviticus 24:22 which says “This law applies to all of you, to Israelites and to foreigners living among you.”
Leviticus 19:15 advises judges to be honest and just and not to show favouritism to the poor or fear the rich.
Even if the role of Magna Carta was to affirm these ideas, it was the Great Charter that gave them impetus in the modern world.
This explains why one of the few surviving copies of the 1297 reissue of the Great Charter was bought by the federal government in 1952 for the ridiculously cheap price of 12,500 pounds. It now resides in Parliament House in Canberra.
Attorney-General Michelle Rowland recognises the significance of having that document within the building that symbolises Australian democracy.
During the week she posted a photograph of the Great Charter on social media and wrote that its influence could still be seen in Australia’s democracy, Constitution and legal system.
The same sentiment is apparent in the United States, which also has a 1297 edition of the Charter.
The US document was purchased in 2007 by a private benefactor for $US21.3 million and given to the US National Archive.
In the 1950s, 9000 American lawyers paid for the American Bar Association to build a monument at Runnymede commemorating the Great Charter.
At its centre is a granite pillar bearing the inscription: “To commemorate Magna Carta – symbol of freedom under the law.”
Chris Merritt is vice-president of the Rule of Law Institute of Australia
To buy a copy of Robin Speed’s book go to https://www.ruleoflaw.org.au/shop


