There were two attempts in Melbourne last week to reform suppression orders. One deserves to be taken seriously.
The other, commissioned by the Melbourne Press Club and produced by journalism academics from Monash University, is flawed.
The serious reform push that matters was produced by lawyers working for the mainstream media and seeks to close a loophole that is eroding the doctrine of open justice.
That loophole was most recently used to prevent the media from revealing that Tom Silvagni, son of a well known former AFL footballer, was on trial for rape.
For 18 months, while Silvagni stood trial, his defence lawyers had persuaded a judge that his mental health would be harmed if his name were made public.
Silvagli was eventually convicted and the suppression order was eventually lifted. But that’s not the point. Open justice was set aside for reasons that few will find persuasive.
After being gagged in the Silvagni case and others, ten publishers and broadcasters last week presented Victorian Attorney-General Sonya Kilkenny with draft legislation that would replace secrecy with common sense.
The media organisations want the government to change the Open Courts Act so suppression orders can only be issued on “safety” grounds if there is a real and substantial risk to the defendant’s physical safety from another person.
This would end the current practice in which well-resourced defendants have been persuading judges to expand the meaning of the word “safety” by arguing that facing criminal charges in open court is a mental health risk.
This plan is backed by The Age, the Herald-Sun, Nine Entertainment, the ABC, radio 3AW, The Guardian, the Seven television network, the Ten network, The Australian and The Australian Financial Review.
Their submission is also backed by the Melbourne Press Club, which commissioned a separate report of its own on the limitations to public interest journalism.
While Kilkenny undertook to give urgent consideration to reforms drawn up by the media’s legal advisers, Victoria’s Chief Justice Richard Niall had a very different response to the separate report produced by journalism academics at Monash.
“It contains a number of misleading claims, selective citations and suppression order data which has been debunked as incomplete and misleading,” Niall said in a statement on March 2.
The data that annoyed the Chief Justice was highlighted by the Press Club which said the Monash report revealed that “Victorian courts are responsible for almost half of the suppression orders issued across Australia”.
This has long been suspected by media lawyers and might well be true. But a suspicion is not a fact.
For such an assertion to be taken seriously it would need to be based on nationally consistent data about every suppression order issued in every state.
It was just 18 months ago that the Federal Court’s Justice Michael Lee delivered a speech in Perth regretting the fact that no such data exists.
This was widely reported at the time, including in Melbourne where The Age quoted Justice Lee as saying:
“To anyone interested in open justice, the sobering reality is that because of the number of courts empowered to suppress material, legacy issues, and the lack of any repositories of data, we simply have no idea how many suppression orders have been made by courts, or how many such orders remain extant,” Lee said.
The authors of the Monash report, Alicia McMillan and Johan Lidberg, did include national statistics on suppression orders.
But it would be a stretch to describe those numbers as reliable.
Most of their report outlines the results of interviews with 12 journalists. It relates their concerns about being denied access to documents and what, according to the reporters, was the hostile attitude of the judiciary towards journalists.
Those are important matters. But the key aspect of the Monash report is the statistics on suppression orders which are presented with a degree of certainty that is unjustified.
It says its figures are “the total raw numbers of issued suppression orders” and are from a 2024 report by the Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom – whose executive director is journalist Peter Greste.
But that is not what the Greste report says. Its says its national figure of 1111 suppression orders is the total number of orders that one media lawyer was notified about by the courts.
It cautioned that its figures were “almost certainly conservative” because the states vary in how they keep their records, what they are required to tell the media and the way in which the rules are applied.
To drive home this warning the Greste report quotes Justice Lee as saying “we simply have no idea how many suppression orders have been made . . . “.
In 2020, legal academic Jason Bosland of Melbourne University wrote that Victoria and South Australia were the only jurisdictions where media organisations were routinely informed of all suppression orders.
“In all other jurisdictions in Australia, media notifications are either incomplete, haphazard, or almost completely non-existent,” he wrote in Media and Arts Law Review.
“This method of data collection has the capacity to result in the gross under-reporting of orders in jurisdictions other than Victoria and South Australia.”
So if the figures for every state except Victoria and South Australia are artificially low, it stands to reason that such a flawed data set would make it possible to depict Victoria as the suppression capital.
All that is necessary is to ignore what Justice Lee said in Perth, the caveats in Greste’s report and Bosland’s warning.


