At its best, the craft of journalism is of almost constitutional importance. It serves the public interest by enabling free societies like ours to make informed choices about how we are governed.
That is why the Albanese government deserves praise for its plan to redress some of the damage that has been inflicted on journalism by giant social media companies and online search engines.
The government’s proposed News Bargaining Incentive aims to strip these companies of 2.25 per cent of their Australian revenue unless they agree to transfer a lesser amount to news organisations to pay for journalism.
These foreign companies deserve no sympathy. They have damaged the business model of the media by republishing news reports to attract advertising and readers.
This has led to the loss of thousands of Australian jobs. And that has eroded the ability of the media to provide the community with reliable news about the state of the nation.
Between 2014-2019 alone, 16,000 media jobs were lost, according to a 2024 report by federal parliament’s joint select committee on social media and Australian society.
The Public Interest Journalism Initiative, which is chaired by Allan Fels, warned the committee that “news market failure” was becoming a more likely prospect across the country.
This was because the producers of public interest journalism faced the overlapping challenges of declining advertising revenue and an increasing reliance on digital platforms for referral traffic.
This is why the government’s initiative deserves support.
The impact of all those job losses is one of the reasons far too many people are turning for their news to social media – which is notoriously biased and unreliable.
For proof, consider how social media spread false reports during the week that the United Nations had decided to confer a global citizenship award on Albanese for what was said to be his inspirational leadership.
In reality, the UN will do no such thing.
False reports about UN involvement gained momentum after the ABC reported that an American think tank, the Atlantic Council, was set to confer its global citizenship award on Albanese in September “on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly”.
The ABC made it clear the award would come from the Atlantic Council – which is a private organisation that has no association with the UN.
Because the Atlantic Council has made no announcement about an award for Albanese, mainstream media outlets that wrote about this incident sourced their coverage to the ABC and accurately reported that the ABC said it would be an award from the Atlantic Council.
The mainstream media is not perfect. The New York Times is proof of that. But when news media publish nonsense, such as the Times’ article about Israeli dogs raping Palestinians, it is because the systems designed to weed out garbage have failed.
On social media, by contrast, there are no systems.
That explains why some references to Albanese’s award on Facebook and X made no reference to the Atlantic Council and referred only to the UN.
That opened the door for others to work themselves into a frenzy over what they described, incorrectly, as the prime minister’s pending “UN” award.
There are two reasons why a UN award for Albanese should have sent alarm bells ringing. The first is that there is no such thing as a UN global citizenship award.
The second reason is that even if such an award did exist, giving it to Albanese would mean the UN had decided to overlook an adverse ruling that was handed down by its own Human Rights Committee just three years ago.
That ruling, in a case brought by businessman Charif Kazal, called for changes after finding this country had breached its international human rights obligations.
The government rejected that finding which prompted human rights lawyer Geoffrey Robertson to deliver his own damning verdict on its human rights record.
Robertson, who represented Kazal, told the UN committee the behaviour of the Albanese government was “redolent of a state party which is eager to pretend to be a supporter of human rights but is in fact an enemy when it comes to criminal justice. It wants the power to defame and demonise its citizens without accountability or responsibility”.
The point here is that many of those who relied on social media for news about Albanese were led up the garden path.
In a democracy, criticism of those elected to public office is healthy – but only when it is based on facts, not fiction spread by social media.
The propensity for this sort of episode is growing.
Research published last year by the University of Canberra found for the first time that social media platforms had overtaken online news sites as the main source of news for many people.
Television remains the most popular source of news, favoured by 37 per cent of people. But social media was the main source of news for 26 per cent compared to just 23 per cent for online news sites.
There is really only one solution to this problem.
The government is heading in the right direction with its News Bargaining Incentive. It has the potential to fill some of the gaps that have emerged in recent years throughout the nation’s newsrooms.
That serves the public interest.
The McKinnon organisation hosted a recent seminar on the future of public interest journalism that was chaired by Peter Greste. I was one of the participants. It’s available on You Tube by searching for Democracy Counts.


