Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
7 May, 2026
Soldiers granted immunity to testify against Roberts-Smith now risk ICC prosecution

When Ben Roberts-Smith eventually faces his war crimes trial in Sydney, four other former soldiers could be in for a nasty surprise.

They have been given immunity from prosecution in return for giving evidence they were complicit, with Roberts-Smith, in unlawful killings during the Afghanistan war.

But while the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions is content to see these four killers go free, that is not the end of the story.

Their immunity deals cannot prevent the International Criminal Court from launching its own investigation. And because they have provided statements outlining their involvement, it is difficult to see how the ICC can turn a blind eye to Australia’s refusal to bring them to justice.

Nobody should be affronted if this international court decides to investigate these four men despite their immunity deal.

That is exactly what the Howard government signed up for when it ratified a treaty in 2002 known as the Rome Statute.

That treaty empowers the ICC to investigate and prosecute war crimes when nations party to that treaty are unable or unwilling to do so. Australia has fulfilled that condition.

What these men have said about Roberts-Smith has yet to be tested, and jurors will make up their own minds about how much weight to place on testimony that is part of their immunity deal.

But the admissions about their own conduct leave no room for doubt. They engaged in unlawful killings and Australia is unwilling to bring them to justice.

The ICC has clearly stated that domestic grants of immunity have no effect on its jurisdiction over war crimes.

This was spelled out by the court’s Pre-Trial Chamber in 2019 in a case involving Saif Al-Islam Gaddafi, son of the late Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi, who claimed he was the beneficiary of an amnesty.

“There is a strong, growing, universal tendency that grave and systematic human rights violations – which may amount to crimes against humanity by their very nature – are not subject to amnesties or pardons under international law,” the Pre-Trial Chamber said.

In 2009, before Lorraine Finlay became Australia’s Human Rights Commissioner, she took a similar view.

Finlay wrote in the University of California Davis Journal of International Law and Policy that allowing states to shield people from prosecution by the ICC “would make a mockery of the system of international criminal justice”.

If the ICC does take an interest in Australia’s refusal to bring these men to justice it could turn the Roberts-Smith case on its head.

The Victoria Cross winner has denied any wrongdoing and if a jury agrees, the rule against double jeopardy would place him beyond the reach of the ICC.

But regardless of the outcome, the fate of the four men who intend to give evidence against him will be up to the ICC’s prosecutor, British barrister Karim Asad Ahmad Khan KC, who is on leave over allegations of sexual misconduct.

If a jury sides with Roberts-Smith and Khan decides to investigate, the tables would be turned: Australia’s most decorated living soldier would be free and his four accusers would be at risk of prosecution and life in prison.

At that point, the Albanese government would have little choice but to become involved.

In 2002, when the Howard government ratified the Rome Statute, it introduced legislation giving the federal attorney-general a veto on whether to arrest those who are sought by the ICC.
So If Khan wants those four men, Attorney-General Michelle Rowland would be in the hot seat.

The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, which is part of Rowland’s portfolio responsibilities but acts independently, has already decided they should not be prosecuted.

If the ICC takes an interest in them, Australia’s reputation would be on line.

Would this country decide, for a second time, that they should not face justice over unlawful killings during wartime?

If Khan is held at bay, how would this square with the Attorney-General’s decision in April to sign off on the DPP’s proposal to prosecute Roberts-Smith?

When Australia ratified the Rome Statute, former Attorney-General Daryl Williams told parliament the ICC represented the international community’s determination to put an end to impunity for the perpetrators of the most serious crimes.

“Australia has a hard-won reputation as a champion of human rights and should throw its weight behind a court that will bring to justice the perpetrators of the most heinous international crimes,” Williams said.

He was right. Without the ICC as a fallback, this country would need to come to terms with the fact that impunity blights the civilian system we have put in place to deal with war crimes.

The United States has taken a different course. That country signed the Rome Statute in 2000 but Bill Clinton, who was President at the time, did not send the treaty to the US senate for ratification.

Two years later his successor, George W. Bush, disavowed the Rome Statute in line with longstanding efforts to keep US forces subject only to American law.

The US Congress went further and enacted legislation that the four men in the Roberts-Smith case might one day find relevant. It is known, at least unofficially, as The Hague Invasion Act.

It empowers US Presidents to use “all means necessary and appropriate to bring about the release of any US or allied personnel being detained or imprisoned by, on behalf of, or at the request of the International Criminal Court” which is based at The Hague in the Netherlands.