Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
20 November, 2026
Faith and legal groups unite against Albanese government’s proposed Digital Duty of Care

Next week is the final session of parliament for the year and it presents the Albanese government with a quandary.

 Will it press ahead with its vague plan for a Digital Duty of Care that has been rushed through parliament and repeatedly criticised as “incoherent” by the Law Council of Australia?

Or will it accept that those calling for precision have a point and rewrite this bill in a manner that adheres to the most important principle of legislative drafting: clarity.

Pulling the bill would be a setback for the timeline announced just last month by Communications Minister Anika Wells.

But the cost of proceeding would be much greater: does the government really wish to alienate leaders of the Catholic, Anglican and Jewish communities who are warning they could be censored because of this bill?

The first sign of whether the government has seen the light will emerge on November 20 when the Senate environment and communications committee publishes the report of its inquiry into the Digital Duty of Care Bill.

Confusion is the hallmark of this bill. Key terms are undefined. The type of conduct that would incur liability has been left open-ended and is therefore unlimited.

This bill even proposes to suppress speech that “promotes hostile attitudes” – but only towards women, not men or boys.

The term “hostile attitudes” has itself been left undefined, and so has the term “women” which means there is every likelihood this bill would prevent the promotion of  “hostile attitudes” towards men who identify as women.

Unless wiser heads prevail, this bill would empower the eSafety Commissioner and online service providers to prevent dissemination not just of unlawful information but a vast and open-ended category of lawful information that, in the view of the commissioner, “may” cause serious harm to children.

In September the Law Council, the peak national body of the legal profession, warned that an earlier version of this bill was drafted in a way that risked introducing “incoherence” into the law.

It told the government conduct that might not be actionable under existing civil causes of action, such as defamation and privacy law, might have led to civil penalties under the draft version of the Digital Duty of Care Bill.

Since then, the government has made changes – but not enough.

The Law Council told the senate committee on Wednesday that incoherence is still a problem.

 “The Law Council’s supplementary submission to the exposure draft consultation identified concerns with the risk of incoherence between the (Digital Duty of Care) and existing causes of action, including defamation, serious invasion of privacy, and racial discrimination,” it said in a submission that is available on the committe’s website.

“While there have been amendments to the scope and application of the DDC since its earlier iteration, these concerns remain,” the Law Council said.

The problem with this scheme is conceptual: by keeping it vague, the government is attempting to equip the e-Safety Commission with maximum flexibilty to punish dissemination of information regardless of whether it is unlawful.

There are two issues here that seem to have escaped the attention of the drafters of this bill: the first is that freedom of communication is a fundamental right, not a privilege within the gift of the eSafety Commissioner.

The second problem is that vague restrictions on this freedom have unintended and potentially damaging consequences for those who have done nothing wrong.

Anglican and Catholic bishops, for example, have both warned that this bill has been drafted in a manner that could lead to censorship of Biblical teaching on contentious social issues about sexual ethics and gender identity.

Anglican Bishop Michael Stead warned that if it becomes law a Sunday sermon on a topic such as marriage could be removed from a local parish website without the knowledge of the parish and without the right to contest the removal.

“Decisions as to what is ‘seriously harmful’ and the resulting removal of that content will occur without the public being aware that content was removed,” he wrote in a submission that is available on the senate committee’s website.

Bishop Anthony Percy of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference believes the biggest problem with the Digital Duty of Care Bill is that “it places the power of censorship in the hands of tech companies”.

“In a mature, free, fair society, what you have is legitimate debates about politics, culture, religion and social issues,” he said.

“That’s quite a different issue than the protection of children or those that are more vulnerable, which is absolutely essential in a free, fair society.

“I think the bill has got it mixed up,” Bishop Percy said.

One of the most damaging aspects of this bill was identified by Robert Gregory of the Australian Jewish Association.

He told the senate committee on November 10: “I believe this bill as it is would prevent Jewish organisations from calling out, condemning and exposing instances of antisemitism.”

Communications minister Anika Wells told the National Press Club on October 15 her priority was to have the Digital Duty of Care Bill through parliament by Christmas.

If Gregory’s assessment is correct, that timetable means a law that would prevent Jews from calling out antisemitism would be approved just weeks before the December 14 anniversary of the massacre at Bondi Beach.

 On December 18 Virginia Bell publishes the report of her royal commission into antisemitism and social cohesion.

Instead of silencing Jews and sermons based on the Bible, scrap this bill and start again.