Select Page
Chris Merritt
Legal Affairs Contributor
12 June, 2026
Federal Court justice names six colleagues over ‘egregious’ judgment delays

Just over three years ago when Ian Jackman was welcomed to the bench of the Federal Court his remarks that day provided a hint of what was to come.

He recalled how much he had learned when he was an associate to Bill Gummow, who at the time was a judge of the Federal Court before being elevated to the High Court.

“Working for Bill Gummow gave me the opportunity to witness first hand the dissection of counsel’s arguments with a scalpel and, if I may say so with the greatest respect, without the benefit of anaesthetic,” Justice Jackman said.

During his own time on the Federal Court bench, Justice Jackman has become adept at using the Gummow treatment in pursuit of efficiency and rigour.

This week he took it to a new level unleashing a verbal knife job – not against counsel for some sloppy regulator but against slow judges on his own court.
At the annual fundraising dinner of the Rule of Law Education Centre, he argued that “egregious delays” by some judges in delivering reserved judgments represented a real and growing threat to the rule of law.

He identified seven Federal Court cases in which judgments had been reserved for up to three-and-a-half years.

He then named six current and former judges who were responsible for those cases, calculated how long the parties had been awaiting judgment and dissociated himself from what he said was the “self congratulation” in the court’s annual report about its efficiency.

He named those judges while delivering this year’s Robin Speed memorial address on the rule of law to an audience of judges, politicians, lawyers and teachers.

Delays of the magnitude identified in his address are so extraordinary that some might find them difficult to believe.

But anyone who checks the judgments and case details will see that Justice Jackman’s remarks are factual. They are based on the Federal Court’s own data.

One of the most startling aspects of his list of delayed judgments is that one judge appears twice – Bernard Murphy.
Justice Murphy was responsible for two of the seven cases on the list and took longer to produce judgments in those cases than any of the other judges named by Justice Jackman.

Justice Murphy’s decision in Southernwood v Brambles (No 3) was handed down in April – three-and-a-half years after the hearing.

“Justice Bernard Murphy also heard the case of Gall v Domino’s Pizza Enterprises Ltd, the last day of the hearing having been in November, 2022, three-and-a-half years ago, yet judgment still stands reserved,” Justice Jackman said at Thursday’s dinner.

It is worth noting that three of the judges with the longest delays in handing down rulings are no longer on the bench: the late Lindsay Foster, John Nicholas who retired last year, and Kathleen Farrell who retired in 2023.

After Justice Murphy, the next longest delay on the list is Justice Foster’s decision in Masters v Lombe which was handed down in 2019 “a little over three years after the completion of a trial which lasted only four days, although illness may have been an extenuating circumstance”, Justice Jackman said.

Justice Nicholas’ decision in Toolgen Inc v Fisher (No 2) was handed down in 2023 which was two years and nine-and-a-half months after an eight-day trial.

Justice Farrell’s delay in the case of Smart Education Program v GLGC Australia was unique.

Justice Jackman pointed out that Justice Farrell had reserved judgment for two-and-a-half years and then resigned from the bench in 2023 without producing a judgment.

She “simply walked away into the contented sunset of retirement on a full judicial pension and left it for someone else to be allocated the task of doing the work”.

“Even if that other judge had not been me, I would still be just as ashamed for the institution of the Federal Court,” he said.

The two other judges on Justice Jackman’s list are Katrina Banks-Smith and Scott Goodman who are both still on the bench.

Justice Banks-Smith produced a judgment in Ezy-Fit Engineering Group v Microm Nominees in 2024 which was a little over two years and four months after a 10-day hearing.

Justice Goodman’s ruling in ASIC v Nuix was handed down in April, which was two years and five months after a 16-day trial.

However Justice Jackman pointed out that “His Honour did have the good grace to apologise for the delay”.

Once the shock of these delays is absorbed, the real question is why Justice Jackman decided to expose them to scrutiny?

The text of his address provides the answer:

“Judicial delay in giving judgments constitutes a serious violation of the rule of law’s requirement for the effective and timely administration of justice by those whom the community trusts to be the rule of law’s most committed guardians,” he said.

“Sadly, the greatest single source of unreasonable delay in legal proceedings is typically not delay by lawyers or their clients, but by judges themselves. Who will protect the rule of law from its protectors?

“In the absence of a federal judicial commission, that really only leaves judges themselves to expose the problem and encourage public scrutiny.

“In my view, public criticism should come from within the judiciary itself. As is often said in other contexts, the standards one walks past are the standards one accepts.”

Chris Merritt is vice-president of the Rule of Law Institute of Australia and the Rule of Law Education Centre.

Justice Jackman’s speech and a video of his presentation are available on the website of the Rule of Law Education Centre.

https://www.ruleoflaw.org.au/programs-annual-lecture-2026